Information Technology (IT) vs. Operational Technology (OT) - Cybersecurity Guide

published
October 24, 2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Build Your Dream Network Architecture
Sign up for a 2-week free trial and experience seamless remote access for easy setup and full control with Netmaker.

Information technology (IT) is sometimes confused with operational technology (OT), mainly because some of their functions overlap. However, the two play uniquely different roles, operate in distinct environments, and face slightly different security threats.

What is information technology (IT)?

IT is a broad term for the management and processing of information. It's what drives our computers, networks, software, and data management. The email you check every morning, the customer database your company uses, or even the cloud service where you store your files represent the different ways IT facilitates the processing, storage, and sharing of information.

In a corporate setting, IT encompasses everything from desktop support to network security. It’s the backbone of the office environment. 

Have you ever called the help desk because your computer wouldn't cooperate? Or perhaps you've been amazed at how quickly a software upgrade rolls out across an entire company. That's the IT department working behind the scenes. They ensure that your digital tools and infrastructure run smoothly.

Cybersecurity in IT involves protecting these systems and data from external threats. It protects systems from phishing, malware, and other scams that try to steal your sensitive information. IT security measures will include firewalls, antivirus software, and encryption techniques to safeguard against such attacks. 

When your organization implements two-factor authentication before you can log in to sensitive applications, for example, that's part of IT’s protective shield.

So, IT focuses on data, connectivity, and digital integrity. IT security, therefore, is about defending your virtual landscapes where data is everything. So, whether it's protecting email servers or ensuring that a virtual private network (VPN) is secure, the IT department's cybersecurity team aims to keep your digital spaces safe.

What is operational technology (OT)?

Operational technology encompasses control systems and processes that manage and monitor physical operations. This could be the big machinery in a factory, the heating and cooling systems in a smart building, or even the grid that supplies electricity to your home.

In a company, OT might encompass everything from production line machinery to building management systems. OT works behind the scenes, ensuring that things move, work, and produce in the physical realm. 

If you have marveled at how factories churn out thousands of products in a day or how traffic lights adjust their patterns based on real-time traffic conditions, that was OT working in the background to ensure essential physical processes tick over smoothly.

Cybersecurity in operational technology entails protecting these tangible systems from digital threats. These threats could take the form of a hacker trying to take control of a water treatment plant's controls or tamper with a manufacturing line. 

OT security measures are there to prevent such threats, keeping the physical operations secure. This might involve using specialized firewalls to shield industrial control systems or ensuring that only authorized personnel can access critical hardware. Your company might also use network segmentation to isolate operational systems from the main IT network.

Unlike IT, which deals with data and digital connectivity, OT bridges the gap between the digital and the physical world. Your cybersecurity tools shield these critical systems where the physical and digital worlds meet. 

Whether it's protecting the sensors on a wind turbine or ensuring a remote access system for a pipeline is secure, OT cybersecurity ensures your physical processes keep running safely.

Key differences between Information Technology (IT) and Operational Technology (OT)

Primary functions

The main function of IT is to manage digital information. This includes handling data storage, system administration, and network management. 

So an IT department at a company would be responsible for tasks like ensuring that email systems are running smoothly, managing cloud-based databases, and overseeing company-wide software installations. These tasks are essential for maintaining the day-to-day digital operations of a business. 

IT teams work tirelessly to ensure that your digital tools are available and efficient, supporting tasks like data analysis, communication, and collaboration across various platforms.

On the other hand, OT's primary functions are rooted in controlling and monitoring physical processes. So at a factory where precision is key OT ensures that machinery operates correctly, production lines move seamlessly, and safety protocols are followed. 

Essentially, OT ensures that the physical systems, like conveyor belts or robotic arms, work without a hitch. In an environment like a power plant, OT is responsible for monitoring the control systems that manage electricity distribution, ensuring everything runs without interruption. The focus is on operational efficiency and safety, often relying on real-time data to make quick adjustments.

Security priorities

Security priorities for IT primarily center around data protection -  keeping your digital information safe. You have a duty to ensure that customer data, internal communications, and sensitive documents are secure from prying eyes. 

For instance, encrypting files ensures that only authorized personnel can access them. Another priority is defending against common cyber threats, like malware or ransomware. You will use antivirus software and firewalls as your digital shields. 

A good example is setting up multi-factor authentication for accessing critical systems. This reduces the risk of unauthorized access, like an extra lock on a door.

With OT, security priorities look a little different. Here, the focus is on protecting physical operations. Among the threats you will protect your physical infrastructure from are hackers. 

A hacker could try to shut down a factory's production line. That's a nightmare scenario for OT teams. To prevent this, you secure industrial control systems with specialized firewalls and network segmentation. This is like having security guards at every door. 

Take a smart building, for example. OT teams ensure that only authorized personnel can control the HVAC systems. You don't want anyone tampering with the temperature settings remotely. 

Another key priority is ensuring real-time data integrity. In a power plant, sensors must provide accurate information at all times. Any disruption can lead to operational chaos.

In both worlds, mitigating the consequences of a breach is crucial. In IT, a data breach can lead to severe financial and reputational damage. Think of a leak of customer information—it can erode trust instantly. 

In OT, a security lapse could result in physical harm or damage. For example, tampered sensors could cause machinery to malfunction. That's why, in OT, the priority extends beyond prevention to ensuring quick recovery and incident response.

These differing priorities shape how you must approach security in IT and OT. While IT focuses on safeguarding the digital realm, OT’s priority is maintaining the safety and continuity of physical operations. Both are essential, but they require distinct strategies and tools to address their unique challenges and vulnerabilities.

Network architecture

IT has a structured network environment. Everything is designed for connectivity and data flow. Think about a typical office setting: you've got computers connected through Ethernet or Wi-Fi, all leading back to a central server. This server manages file storage, email, and centralized applications. It's like a well-organized library where every book has its place. 

Routers and switches form the backbone, directing traffic to ensure smooth communication. For example, when you send an email, it travels through these devices to reach its destination seamlessly. 

Firewalls stand guard at the network perimeter, filtering out unwanted traffic and potential threats. It's a neat system designed for efficient data exchange and robust security.

On the OT side, network architecture has a different flavor. The focus is on reliability and real-time communication. On a factory floor, for example, machinery and control systems need to interact constantly. 

OT systems don't always speak the same language as IT networks. Instead, they might use protocols like Modbus or Profibus, which are tailored for industrial environments. Imagine an assembly line where precision is key. In OT, devices are sometimes connected in a more linear or star configuration, ensuring quick and direct communication. 

For instance, a sensor on a conveyor belt must immediately relay information to the control unit to adjust its speed. OT networks are often isolated from IT networks through segmentation, creating a security barrier to prevent cross-network threats.

Unlike IT, where flexibility and interconnectivity are priorities, OT networks are designed with stability and security in mind. The communication must be predictable and uninterrupted. 

In a power plant, for example, you can't afford a lost packet or delayed data. Everything needs to function in real time to keep operations running smoothly. This environment also places a strong emphasis on physical security. Servers and control systems might be housed in secure locations, accessible only to authorized personnel, adding another layer of protection.

So, while IT network architecture is built for data flow and versatility, OT networks prioritize the reliability and integrity of physical operations. Each serves its purpose, driven by the unique demands of its environment.

Cybersecurity threats in IT

Phishing

Phishing is where attackers try to trick you into revealing sensitive information through deceptive emails. They could do this through an email that looks like it’s from your bank, but clicking the link sends your login details straight to a hacker. It’s sneaky and all too common.

Malware

Malware is like a digital virus that can infect computers and networks. Ransomware, a type of malware, is particularly insidious. It locks you out of your data until you pay a ransom. Just think of a hospital unable to access patient records because of a ransomware attack. It’s a nightmare scenario.

Insider threats

These can be malicious employees or simply careless ones. Someone might mistakenly send sensitive documents to the wrong email address or download unauthorized software that opens the door for an attack. The human factor can be a weak link, even in the most well-protected systems.

Vulnerabilities in software and systems

Hackers exploit these weaknesses, often using automated tools to find and attack exposed systems. Bypassing outdated security patches can give them unauthorized access, like a burglar finding an open window in a house. We’ve seen this with high-profile breaches where attackers used unpatched systems to infiltrate networks.

Data breaches

Data breaches can occur when attackers gain access to databases holding sensitive information. Imagine an e-commerce site’s customer database being compromised, exposing thousands of credit card numbers. This kind of breach can lead to significant financial and reputational damage.

Denial-of-Service (DoS)

Here, attackers overwhelm a system with traffic, causing it to slow down or crash. It’s like a digital traffic jam that halts operations. A common example is when a company’s website goes offline during a major sales event due to a DoS attack, resulting in lost revenue and frustrated customers.

Each day brings new threats, keeping IT security teams on high alert. You must constantly update your software, educate staff about security practices, and implement robust measures to guard against these ever-evolving dangers. Cybersecurity in IT isn’t just about technology; it’s about staying one step ahead in a game where the rules are always changing.

Cybersecurity threats in OT

Unauthorized access

This is where hackers target industrial control systems. For example, someone might gain control of a manufacturing plant’s control room. It's terrifying to think about the disruption that could cause. They could halt production, manipulate machinery settings, or even cause equipment failure.

Ransomware

Just like in IT, ransomware can lock down essential systems. But here, the stakes are even higher. Picture a water treatment facility being held hostage. Without access to critical control systems, the distribution of clean water could be compromised, affecting entire communities. This makes OT systems particularly attractive targets for cybercriminals looking to cause chaos or extract ransom.

Insider threats

Here, employees with legitimate access might, either intentionally or accidentally, cause disruptions. Consider a maintenance worker inadvertently uploading malicious software via a USB stick. This could lead to a system shutdown or provide a gateway for external attackers. The human element poses a significant risk, requiring ongoing vigilance and training.

Outdated systems

Many OT environments still rely on legacy equipment that's vulnerable to attacks. These older systems often lack modern security safeguards, making them easy targets. Think about an old control system in a power plant that hasn’t been updated in years. An attacker exploiting this vulnerability could have a direct impact on energy distribution.

Denial-of-Service attacks

In OT, these can disrupt critical operations by overwhelming systems with traffic, similar to an IT scenario. Imagine the chaos if a transport network’s control system went offline due to such an attack. Trains could halt unexpectedly, schedules would be thrown off, and passenger safety could be compromised.

Physical sabotage through digital means

A bad actor might alter sensor readings or control settings, causing machinery to operate outside safe parameters. Picture an unauthorized adjustment to a sensor on a chemical plant's reactor, leading to potential safety hazards. The seamless interaction between digital controls and physical processes makes these kinds of attacks particularly dangerous.

In OT, the consequences of cyber threats reach far beyond digital loss, impacting real-world safety and operations. It’s a sobering reminder that while technology advances, the security measures protecting it must keep pace, safeguarding the critical infrastructure that underpins our daily lives.

Main challenges in securing IT systems

The dynamic nature of cyber threats

Attacks are constantly evolving, requiring you to stay vigilant and adapt quickly. For example, phishing schemes have become more sophisticated, often mimicking trusted brands to trick even the savviest users. This means you must continually educate employees on recognizing and avoiding these traps.

The vast number of devices and users on a network

In large organizations, it's not uncommon to have hundreds or even thousands of devices connected at any time. Each one is a potential entry point for an attacker. 

Consider the complexity of maintaining up-to-date security patches across all systems. A single unpatched device can be the weak link that compromises the entire network. 

And when employees bring their own devices to work, it adds another layer of complexity. Ensuring these personal devices adhere to security policies is a constant battle.

Challenges in securing OT systems

Legacy systems

Take a power plant, for example. It might rely on control systems that have been in place for decades. These older systems often lack modern security features and can be highly vulnerable to attack. Retrofitting them with updated security can be difficult, costly, and sometimes even impossible without disrupting operations.

Real-time performance and reliability

In OT, traditional IT security measures, like patching and updates, can be challenging to implement without causing downtime. Imagine a factory that can't afford to stop production even for a moment. Balancing security with uninterrupted operations is a tightrope walk. 

Plus, OT systems often use specialized protocols that are unfamiliar to most IT professionals, making it harder to apply standard security practices.

Securing the communication between digital and physical elements

For instance, an attacker could intercept and alter signals between a sensor and a control system, causing physical processes to go awry. It’s a different kind of threat landscape, where the consequences of a breach can be immediate and tangible.

On both sides, IT and OT teams often face the challenge of working in silos. Each has its own priorities and ways of working. In IT, the focus is on protecting data integrity and confidentiality, while OT prioritizes safety and operational continuity. 

Bridging these two worlds is crucial but often easier said than done. Collaboration is key, but it requires effort and understanding from both sides to effectively secure the overall environment.

Ultimately, the challenge lies in developing a cohesive strategy that addresses the unique needs of IT and OT while protecting both the digital and physical assets of an organization.

Convergence of IT and OT

The convergence of IT and OT is becoming more common as technology advances. It’s driven by the need for more efficient operations and better decision-making. 

Imagine a factory floor where sensors and machines are connected to IT systems, enabling real-time data collection and analysis. This integration allows for predictive maintenance, reducing downtime and saving money.

As IT and OT merge, so do their cybersecurity challenges. One big hurdle is aligning the different priorities of each domain. IT focuses on protecting data and ensuring compliance. Meanwhile, OT is all about reliability and safety. 

So, it is possible that an IT team might implement strict security measures that might inadvertently disrupt a production line. There’s a need for balance; a need to protect digital assets without compromising physical operations.

Another challenge is integrating disparate systems. IT systems are often standardized and updated regularly. In contrast, OT systems can be bespoke and legacy-based. 

Think of an older manufacturing plant where OT systems haven’t been touched for years. Bringing these systems under one cybersecurity umbrella is tricky. It requires careful planning and collaboration. You must ensure that security measures protect both the digital and physical realms without causing unnecessary interference.

Despite the challenges, the convergence of IT and OT opens exciting possibilities. For example, in a smart building, IT systems can integrate with OT systems to optimize energy use. Sensors collect data on occupancy and temperature, allowing the system to adjust lighting and HVAC settings automatically. This kind of integration enhances operational efficiency and contributes to sustainability efforts.

However, this convergence creates new vulnerabilities. Connecting OT systems to IT networks can make them more susceptible to cyber threats. 

Imagine a cyber attacker using an IT network to gain access to OT systems, potentially disrupting critical processes. To combat these risks, network segmentation is crucial. By isolating OT networks, you can limit the potential damage of an attack. It’s like having a firewall specifically tailored for the physical processes involved.

The convergence of IT and OT is a journey. It requires both technical and cultural shifts. IT and OT teams must work together, share knowledge, and develop a mutual understanding. Each has something valuable to offer, and by collaborating, you can create a more secure and efficient environment. 

As these two domains continue to blend, you must stay agile and adaptable, always ready to address the unique challenges and seize the opportunities that arise.

Best practices for IT and OT cybersecurity

Create a strong security culture

In IT, this means constantly educating employees about the latest phishing scams and the importance of strong, unique passwords. 

For example, always encourage your team to use password managers to keep track of complex credentials. And don't forget multi-factor authentication; it’s like having a deadbolt in addition to a regular lock on your digital doors.

In the OT world, a focus on security culture involves regular training on recognizing and reporting unusual activities on the factory floor. 

For instance, if a machine starts behaving oddly or slows down unexpectedly, it could be more than just a mechanical issue. You must constantly remind your colleagues to report such anomalies immediately, as they could be the first signs of a cyber threat.

Implement network segmentation

This is a critical practice. In IT, we segment networks to contain potential threats. Imagine if a hacker got into one department's server—it would be disastrous if they could easily traverse the entire network. 

By using VLANs, you can ensure that sensitive areas, like payroll systems, are isolated. This way, even if one area is breached, the threat is contained. 

For OT, network segmentation is just as crucial, if not more so. Here, isolating control systems from general IT networks prevents threats from traveling between them. 

If you manage cybersecurity at a water treatment facility: ensure the control systems are on a separate network from the office computers. This will reduce the number of potential attack vectors you must deal with.

Regularly update and patch your software

In IT, it’s crucial to schedule regular checks to ensure all systems are up-to-date. It's like keeping your car well-maintained to avoid breakdowns. 

However, in OT, this task is more complex due to the need for continuous operations. Therefore, you must work with OT teams to identify the best times for updates, ensuring there's minimal disruption. Sometimes, that means sneaking in updates during late-night shifts or scheduled maintenance windows.

Implement access control

This is an area where both IT and OT can learn from each other. In IT, you can use role-based access controls to ensure employees only access what's necessary for their roles. This reduces the risk of insider threats. 

For OT, this means implementing strict access controls on physical devices. Ensure that only authorized personnel have the clearance to adjust machine settings or interact with control systems, often using biometric authentication for added security.

Develop an incident response plan

In IT, you must conduct regular drills to ensure everyone knows their role if a breach occurs. Quick, coordinated action can limit damage. In OT settings, these drills include scenarios that could impact physical operations, like a sudden shutdown of production lines. Both IT and OT teams must be involved so they can respond effectively to any threat, digital or physical.

Build Your Dream Network Architecture
Sign up for a 2-week free trial and experience seamless remote access for easy setup and full control with Netmaker.
More posts

GET STARTED

A WireGuard® VPN that connects machines securely, wherever they are.
Star us on GitHub
Can we use Cookies?  (see  Privacy Policy).